OK, at the risk of getting myself on some Government hit list, I really want to share this.
The other day Dawn and I were watching The Majestic with Jim Carey. I really enjoyed the movie. It takes place during the McCarthyism Anti-Communism hearings.
Watching how ludicrous the hearings and investigations were depicted it made me shake my head. It reminded me of the Salem Witch Trials of 1692 America. I remember my father telling me that the real witches during those trials were the ones making the acquisitions (although not the kind of witches they were hunting for). So I figured the communists, or at least the anti-Americans (subversives, etc.) were the ones orchestrating the McCarthyism trials.
Anyway, I shook my head and thought to myself of George Santayana’s quote “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” Naturally I was glad that modern America is beyond that sort of stillness.
Then I started wondering if we really were. Maybe this pattern it repeating itself. Salem didn’t invent it (look at the Spanish Inquisition), so it probably won’t end with McCarthyism. So could I think of an example today? The first thing I came up with was the detention center in Guantanamo Bay (Gitmo).
Lets look at the similarities between the three: Salem, McCarthy and Gitmo:
| Salem | McCarthy | Gitmo |
|---|---|---|
| Accused called Witches | Accused called Communists | Accused called enemy combatants |
| All three labels are designed to trigger hate and fear from the public at large. Just having the label attached is a conviction as to deny was seen as a sign of guilt. Basic rights are waived because of the label. The accused were given an opportunity to turn others in to save their own skin. | ||
| Part of the Puritan’s war on Satan / Evil | Part of the US war against The Communism Party (which organized unions!) | Part of the US War on Terror |
| Many accusers apologized when they realized their errors (after the fact). | Most punishments were later overturned, etc. | Yet to be seen. |
In researching this I discovered I am by far not the first to draw these parallels which is not surprising. I was surprised to find out that considering this now makes me a Liberal Democrat. Hmm . . . interesting.

No Responses to “Is Gitmo the new Salem?”
Please Wait
Leave a Reply